By Jordan Baker, Founder of Fair Public Relations and former UK national journalist
Hiring somebody to run PR internally can make sense when a business has continuous communications work, several stakeholders to coordinate and enough budget to recruit, train and supervise a capable employee. Outsourcing often suits a lean company that has genuine expertise or news but lacks the editorial writing and journalist outreach capacity to turn it into usable opportunities.
A hybrid arrangement can work especially well: the business owns its facts and decisions, while an outside specialist handles agreed media preparation and pitching. There is no universally cheaper route until you compare the actual jobs and their full costs.
I am Jordan Baker, founder of Fair Public Relations and a former UK national journalist. An employee who understands the business inside out may still lack time or experience to pitch a reporter effectively. An experienced external agency may understand media requirements but cannot know private product facts without the founder's cooperation. The decision is not a contest between loyalty and expertise. It is about choosing where responsibility, time and editorial judgement should sit for the amount of genuine work the business actually has.
What does running PR in-house actually mean?
Small-business owners often use 'in-house PR' to describe three different arrangements. The founder may handle media calls themselves, a general marketing employee may add publicity to an already demanding job, or the company may hire a specialist whose principal responsibility is communications. Those models have very different capacity and cost implications. A founder spending three hours a month on press questions is not equivalent to a full-time communications manager.
Founder-led work offers direct access to the person who knows the company best. It can be efficient when the business has a straightforward specialist subject and occasional relevant questions. The cost is the owner's time and the risk that journalist deadlines lose out to customers, operations or family life. A founder can be an excellent source and still struggle to research publications or draft polished material under pressure.
An existing marketing employee may handle company news, social content and product communications well, but earned-media pitching requires additional judgement. They must identify what a reporter needs, offer evidence rather than promotion and handle rejection constructively. If PR is merely added to an already full workload, the company should not expect a specialist service to appear without allocating time.
A dedicated PR employee can build institutional knowledge and handle daily internal relationships. Yet hiring brings recruitment, supervision, leave, development, employer obligations and the need to evaluate the person's actual professional strengths. Every in-house model also requires somebody authorised to speak accurately for the business.
What does an external PR agency do instead?
An external PR agency undertakes work defined by its contract. In a journalist-led earned-media programme, that may include understanding the company, developing plausible story angles, preparing source material, pitching appropriate reporters, following up and explaining the response. The agency may bring media writing experience and a broader perspective on which parts of a company's activity are newsworthy.
Outsourcing does not mean buying a publication slot. A reporter decides whether the story suits their readers and may refuse, delay or alter it. Nor does an external firm automatically become the business's marketing department. Paid advertising, employee communications, social media, technical SEO, investor relations and crisis advice can be separate functions outside the agreed scope.
Different external services also have different roles. Fair PR's Outsourced PR Services page describes how a business can use Standard PR rather than employ its own press office. The narrower Expert Commentary PR service is for an eligible individual with real subject expertise who mainly needs suitable commentary drafted and pitched. It cannot substitute for a wider product-launch or founder-positioning campaign.
The client's part remains fundamental. The agency needs truthful background, prompt confirmation of claims, permission to use images or anecdotes and access to the spokesperson. Outsourcing can provide specialist editorial work, but it cannot manufacture a product's credentials, make confidential information public or replace the owner's commercial decisions.
Who needs control of the story, and who needs editorial judgement?
The business should retain control over what it knows: product specifications, sensitive information, the legal position, client permissions and who has authority to speak. An internal employee may hear about a development before an outsider does. They can quickly confirm facts with managers, understand which announcements are premature and recognise when a customer example must remain confidential.
The publicist's editorial judgement concerns something different. A journalist is not obliged to publish a company's chosen slogan. A business statement such as 'we are delighted to be expanding our innovative range' might be appropriate for the company's own website, but tells a reporter little. A defensible story would identify what actually changed, why readers should care and which claims can be checked.
As a former national journalist, I would rather receive a precise explanation of a consumer problem from a knowledgeable source than a polished paragraph with no evidence. The best external consultant can challenge a weak premise. A skilled in-house specialist can do exactly the same. What matters is whether anyone has permission to say that an announced milestone is not independently newsworthy.
Editorial control ultimately rests with the publisher. Internal ownership of facts and agency judgement about pitchability should work together, not compete. A clear approval owner can protect accuracy while allowing the team to respond within a reporter's deadline.
When does it make sense to keep PR in-house?
An internal hire may be sensible when the company has sustained communications demands well beyond occasional external coverage. That could include daily questions from staff, several business units, a complex leadership team, ongoing stakeholder communication and a substantial stream of genuinely relevant developments. An employee who is available to departments each day can coordinate those activities in a way a narrow earned-media retainer is not designed to replicate.
A growing organisation may also need someone to manage long-term institutional knowledge. Internal employees can build relationships across teams, organise confidential material and understand how one public statement affects a dozen other responsibilities. Recruitment and training can be worthwhile when the workload is both consistent and broad enough to occupy a suitable person.
The important qualification is capability. A marketing generalist who is already responsible for advertising, events and customer campaigns may not have time to develop original journalist pitches. A business should be honest about whether it is funding a specialist role or simply hoping a current employee will somehow absorb extra work.
For sensitive matters involving regulated communications, investor relations or complex crises, the company may need specialist internal leadership and qualified outside advisers. A routine small-business PR retainer should not be assumed to cover those responsibilities. When internal coordination is continuous and critical, an accountable employee can be the better operational choice.
When does outsourcing make more sense?
Outsourcing is often practical when the business has genuine material journalists might need, but not enough daily activity to justify recruiting a specialist employee. A founder with useful professional knowledge may be interrupted by sporadic interview requests. A consumer brand may have seasonal product angles and credible founder stories without requiring a full-time press office. An external team can handle agreed research, drafting and pitching while the owner runs the business.
It can also make sense when an existing marketing team is competent at advertising and customer communications but lacks newsroom experience. The external specialist can focus on original earned-media opportunities rather than retrain everybody or leave important outreach to the end of a busy week.
There is a trade-off. An agency does not sit in internal meetings all day and may need deliberate briefing to understand product changes. It can miss developments if the client never shares them, and every external provider has its own workload and availability. Before buying, confirm who will supply information, approve claims and answer time-sensitive questions.
I would not recommend outsourcing simply because an agency sounds inexpensive next to a full-time salary. The correct question is whether the business needs a particular mix of editorial skills and professional work without creating an ongoing role. If it does, a defined service can be commercially sensible.
Is in-house PR really cheaper than an agency?
A meaningful comparison begins with the total cost of the particular work, not a headline salary against a monthly agency fee. An employee's cost may include agreed pay, country-specific employer taxes or contributions, benefits, pension obligations, recruitment, onboarding, software, training, equipment, annual leave cover and management time. The amounts depend on the actual contract and jurisdiction. The UK, United States and Canada have different employer rules, and even states or provinces may differ.
An agency arrangement usually has a specified retainer and contract period, with any extras identified separately. The business must still account for founder time, specialist approvals, photographs, product samples and out-of-scope services if those are necessary. These do not always arise, and an agency should say who pays. Fair PR currently prices its broader Standard PR at £797 per month UK, US$997 US and CAD$1,497 Canada. Those are actual service fees, not annual employee costs.
Imagine a hypothetical employee whose stated annual salary is S, with additional employer-related costs E, recruitment and onboarding R, tools and training T and manager time M. The actual first-year resource cost is S + E + R + T + M, with each variable based on genuine local circumstances. For outsourcing, the calculation is agreed fees over the chosen term + approved extras + the value of the internal time required. The formula is more useful than an unsourced assertion that all PR managers earn a particular amount.
The comparison must be like-for-like. A full-time employee may work on internal communications, reputation issues, campaigns and daily coordination that Fair PR's Standard service does not include. Conversely, an agency may supply specialised journalist writing and outreach without the company having to recruit. One route can cost less while offering fewer hours and different responsibilities. That is not a contradiction; it is the decision the business must make.
What work still belongs to you after outsourcing?
The founder or internal team remains the source of truth. Nobody outside the company can independently validate a specialist's qualifications, confirm an unpublished financial result or grant permission to disclose a client's story. The business must supply appropriate professional background, factual evidence, usable product details, imagery rights and the names of people authorised to approve public statements.
Journalists often work to deadlines that do not align with a convenient monthly client call. Someone needs to answer a factual question, review a draft quote or arrange a spokesperson quickly enough to keep the opportunity viable. A business that repeatedly takes weeks to approve a simple accurate comment may struggle even with a capable external team.
The agency should explain what it needs and why. For a service business, the most useful source material may come from the founder's direct experience or a client who has consented to speak. For a product brand, it could be exact specifications, stock, press-ready images and a sample. A qualified professional may need to review sensitive technical or regulatory claims.
Outsourcing removes some execution work but not accountability for your own information. The best partnership gives the agency reliable input and the freedom to turn it into relevant, accurate material. It does not ask the PR team to invent facts simply to produce another pitch this week.
How do speed, journalist access and consistency compare?
An existing internal employee may recognise a news opportunity immediately because they know the business and sit close to decision-makers. They can often obtain internal documents or approvals more quickly than an outside agency that needs to schedule a briefing. If the company's priorities change every day, this proximity can be especially useful.
An experienced external team may be faster at recognising which reporters cover the issue, editing a source's explanation and developing a concise credible pitch once the facts are provided. That is a skill advantage, not a guarantee of personal access to a named editor. Journalists respond to relevant information, independent news priorities and deadlines. An agency cannot sell a relationship as though it obliges a newspaper to publish.
Continuity creates risks in both models. An employee can take leave or resign, taking hard-won institutional understanding with them unless knowledge is documented. An agency can change account teams or require a handover. The sensible safeguard is a clear briefing record, current source materials, named responsibility and an honest process for urgent questions.
Do not overcomplicate that system. A shared folder of approved facts, one internal decision-maker and a clear contact can often serve a small business. What matters is that there is no confusion about who can answer a journalist or approve a correction when the deadline approaches.
Can an agency work alongside an in-house marketing person?
Often this is one of the most practical arrangements. An internal marketer understands the company's offers, calendar and existing customer communications. They can keep a list of verified developments, identify credible internal experts and approve the way a campaign represents the business. The external team can contribute earned-media research, journalism-led writing and relevant pitching within its agreed scope.
A simple division of responsibilities is usually enough. The internal person holds the accurate source material and one approval route; the agency develops suitable media angles, manages outreach and reports what has actually happened. A regular conversation can review upcoming developments and whether there is genuine journalist interest. This avoids assigning two people to send inconsistent messages to the same reporter.
A hybrid also offers a useful way to test the workload before hiring a full-time specialist. The internal employee can learn what genuine media requests demand and what the external team must spend time producing. If ongoing communications later become a substantial daily function, the company can decide whether more work should be brought inside.
One caution is duplicated responsibility. If the marketing employee believes the agency is handling every business announcement while the agency expects the employee to supply all approved facts, nothing moves. The written scope should say who owns each step without inventing another layer of meetings or an elaborate management board.
How should you measure in-house and outsourced PR fairly?
The same goal should be used for both routes. Define the audiences and credible stories first, then distinguish work done, publisher responses, published coverage and any genuine downstream business outcome. A staff member's busy calendar is not proof of editorial impact, but an agency's outreach log is not proof of it either.
AMEC's Integrated Evaluation Framework provides a useful distinction between communication activity, outputs, audience responses, outcomes and impact. A small business does not need to recreate the full framework as a dashboard. It needs to avoid confusing a drafted pitch, an editor's question, a completed interview and a published article. Those are different stages, none necessarily guaranteeing a sale.
For example, an internal marketer might develop excellent source material that an external publicist pitches to trade journalists. Whose work produced the eventual article? Both contributed, while the journalist made the publishing decision. Reporting should recognise the joint process instead of manufacturing exclusive attribution to one person.
Measure over a period appropriate to the subject and commissioning cycle. A seasonal product review may take time to test; an expert reply to a topical question could be used quickly or not at all. Ask what was learnt and what should change. Avoid advertising value equivalency as a substitute for evidence of actual audience relevance or commercial benefit.
Could a freelancer or a one-off project be better?
Sometimes the need is narrow enough that neither a permanent employee nor an ongoing agency retainer is justified. A business might need to prepare a press kit for a defined launch, improve an executive biography or obtain a specialist review of its public messaging. A properly scoped one-off project or experienced freelancer may be sufficient for that task.
A single professional can offer valuable experience and flexibility, but the client should consider availability, cover and the breadth of work the person actually provides. A full retained agency may be more practical for a continuing programme with several story routes. These are different external models rather than a simple hierarchy of quality.
Fair PR's existing guide to freelance consultants versus agencies covers the trade-offs in depth, while its article on retainers versus one-off campaigns explains why project timing changes what you are buying. This article's central decision remains whether the business should employ communications capacity at all, not which external supplier type always wins.
If the need disappears after the project, the less permanent option may be financially sensible. If the business consistently generates substantial developments and needs daily internal coordination, a permanent role may later be more appropriate. Be willing to reassess the decision as actual workload changes.
What if the founder wants to handle their own PR?
DIY earned-media outreach can make sense for an informed founder who has the time to learn a publication's needs and respond reliably. Begin with a brief factual biography and one genuine area of expertise. Identify a specific question a reporter's audience might need answered, gather substantiating information and research the publications that actually cover it.
A useful pitch should explain the reader benefit quickly. Do not email every journalist with an introduction about how passionate the company is. Approach a small number of appropriate writers, describe a defensible angle, provide suitable evidence and be available for questions. A concise, accurate answer to a genuine reporter enquiry may achieve more than a long unrequested company history.
Keep a simple record of what was sent, any reply, any additional evidence requested and whether an article genuinely appeared. Do not treat a journalist's polite interest as publication. Also recognise your own opportunity cost: founder hours spent drafting speculative pitches are hours not spent serving customers or developing the business.
The Fair PR DIY PR guide provides a fuller starting process. If the founder later finds that worthwhile opportunities are being missed because time is scarce, they can reconsider external support. There is no reason to employ an agency simply because DIY is unfashionable; the issue is whether the work is being done well and sustainably.
How would the decision change for three different businesses?
Consider a hypothetical small cleaning company with a founder who knows seasonal household problems exceptionally well. Its best media route might be useful, accurate advice for local consumer journalists or an occasional business story. If the owner has time to answer suitable questions and can handle a few targeted approaches, DIY or narrow expert-commentary support might be enough. Hiring a dedicated full-time PR employee could be excessive. The bottleneck is usually the founder's time and ability to provide genuinely useful evidence.
Now consider a fictional technical consultancy serving organisations under confidentiality agreements. The company may possess highly relevant professional knowledge but be unable to disclose its clients or project specifics. An internal decision-maker must control permissions, confidentiality and source approval. A specialist external team could still develop non-confidential expert commentary, but a hybrid with tight factual oversight is more sensible than asking an agency to invent identifiable case examples.
A third imaginary business is a consumer product start-up preparing a real launch. It needs availability, accurate specifications, usable photography and practical sample logistics. A founder or small internal marketing person must own those facts. An external journalist-led agency may help position the product and reach appropriate editors without creating a permanent hire, but the service must fit the actual scope and lead times. A product that is not ready to buy might be better served by preparation before PR.
The lesson is that industry alone does not decide the resourcing model. News volume, internal approval complexity, editorial opportunity and the business's cash and time determine the trade-off. These examples are illustrations, not audited client stories or promised results.
A practical in-house versus outsourced PR decision table
The comparison is more useful when it forces the company to examine daily capacity, direct subject access, actual professional skill, cost structure, continuity, approval control and realistic reporting. The responsive table in the accompanying implementation pack sets out these factors in four columns with concrete questions to ask.
Treat its rows as a buyer's worksheet, not a universal verdict. If a business has ongoing internal stakeholder demands every working day, a dedicated employee may be efficient even when an agency could handle some media stories. If it has a credible spokesperson and occasional strong editorial angles, external specialist pitching may be appropriate without a new hire. When the company already has a capable marketer but not a publicist, a hybrid can avoid unnecessary duplication.
| Criterion | In-house or founder-led | Outsourced specialist agency | What to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Available daily hours | Dedicated employee may be available daily; founder or marketer may only have spare time | Agreed contracted capacity shared with other account commitments, not a full-time employee | How often is suitable work needed and who can respond to deadlines? |
| Skills and development | Depends on actual employee's journalism experience, training and competing duties | May bring specialist editorial drafting and reporter outreach within chosen brief | Does the person/team genuinely know this editorial format? |
| Internal facts and sources | Close to leaders, products and sensitive evidence; needs authority to use it | Must be briefed and obtain source permission from client | Who owns factual approval and confidential information? |
| Editing and media pitching | Can develop direct relationships, but needs actual reporter research and writing capacity | Typically researches angles and relevant journalists where included; editors still decide | What work is committed and who will do the pitching? |
| Total cost structure | Salary or founder time, local payroll obligations, hiring, management, benefits and tools | Defined retainer/project terms, agreed expenses, client input and outside-scope costs | Are the compared duties and commitment periods actually equivalent? |
| Continuity and handover | Institutional knowledge can develop; leave or resignation may reduce capacity | Account knowledge depends on briefing, documented scope and consistent delivery staff | How is evidence retained and who covers absences? |
| Control and approvals | Internal team may access decision-makers quickly but can be slowed by bureaucracy | Independent editorial viewpoint, but relies on timely internal source sign-off | Who can make an accurate decision before a reporter's deadline? |
| Campaign breadth | One employee may coordinate wider internal and external communications within actual competence | Only agreed specialist earned-media work; not automatically internal, paid, crisis or SEO delivery | Is the need a daily communications role or targeted press activity? |
| Reporting | Must distinguish employee time and completed publicity from actual media outcomes | Should distinguish targeted work, journalist interest, actual articles and outcomes | Can either approach show independently published URLs and proper context? |
| Risks and dependence | Internal blind spots, competing duties, hiring risk and interruption of expertise | Client knowledge gap, unclear exclusions, response delays and changing account staff | Which risk is material, and how will both sides address it? |
Check the real people and contract before applying the table. 'In-house' is not automatically quick, and 'agency' is not automatically experienced in the exact industry. A founder doing PR alongside other work may have less practical capacity than a well-scoped external team, while a senior internal specialist may handle complex situations that a narrow retainer explicitly excludes.
Six questions to answer before spending money
Ask whether the business has something journalists could genuinely use. Is there credible professional knowledge, a relevant product, documented customer information with permission or a meaningful announcement? An internal hire cannot manufacture newsworthiness any more than an outside agency can. If the answer is uncertain, prepare the evidence before committing a large budget.
Next ask how much relevant communications work occurs every week. Does it demand a person in the business daily, or does it consist of occasional media windows?
Third, who actually understands the subject well enough to answer questions and sign off facts?
Fourth, is there one clear person authorised to approve material without allowing every quote to become a slow committee exercise?
Fifth, calculate the actual budget and management time for the initial period. Include employment expenses if hiring, the contract commitment and approved extras if outsourcing, and the time the founder will still contribute.
Sixth, define what meaningful progress would look like: accurate materials, relevant pitches, genuine journalist responses, published stories and business enquiries where evidence exists.
These are not ritual questions to justify an agency. They are decision points. A company with extensive daily communications and a qualified budget may recruit. A lean business with a few suitable stories may outsource. A founder without proof or capacity may sensibly wait.
How does Fair PR fit into these options?
Fair PR is a journalist-led external provider, not a replacement for every employee a business might hire. Our wider Standard PR is intended for appropriate founder and company positioning, products, services, news and genuine earned-media opportunities. It includes strategy, relevant content and direct journalist outreach with account-managed support. Our narrower Expert Commentary PR is for eligible specialists whose real knowledge can help reporters, not a cut-price product-launch or broad communications department.
Standard PR currently costs £797 UK, US$997 US or CAD$1,497 Canada per month. Expert Commentary PR costs £397, US$497 or CAD$747 monthly for qualified individuals. These are separate local market prices, not currency conversions. Both have an initial three-month commitment and one full billing-cycle notice thereafter. The broader service therefore has a different cost and scope from the specialist source-commentary offer.
The Outsourced PR Services page explains the general delivery approach, while Small Business PR gives more context on suitability. Neither service guarantees named publications, specific editorial links, rankings, AI citations or leads. A founder still needs to supply truthful evidence, approve materials and take part in relevant interviews.
For a company with a full-time internal communications workload, a capable employee may be the better purchase. For a founder with no credible current story, preparation may be better than a retainer. We should only recommend external PR where there is a genuine editorial route and a manageable commercial commitment.
So should your small business hire someone or outsource PR?
If daily internal communications, stakeholder coordination and fast access to departments occupy substantial time, an appropriately recruited in-house professional may be the right long-term investment. If the business has occasional but meaningful stories and needs experienced external editing and pitching, an agency may offer the relevant expertise without creating a permanent role. A hybrid can be especially sensible where an existing marketer owns the business context and an external team handles focused media relations.
None of those choices means the company can delegate away the truth of its claims or the final approval of sensitive information. Independent publishers still decide what to use. Even excellent specialist work may produce a quiet month, and an employee with deep business knowledge can struggle to secure coverage if there is no suitable story.
The decision should be reviewed against actual capacity, total cost and evidence of worthwhile activity. Do not hire a person simply to look established, or outsource simply because a monthly fee is easy to compare with a salary. Choose the model that covers the real communications job, respects the company's resources and leaves clear responsibility for what happens next.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to hire a PR manager or use a PR agency?
It depends on the roles and the amount of work. A full-time PR manager's actual employer cost can include salary, legally required contributions, benefits, recruitment, training, leave cover, equipment and management time, with country and local rules affecting the calculation. An agency has an agreed monthly fee and period, possible extra expenses and a continuing need for your input, but normally does not perform every job a full-time employee could. Fair PR's current Standard PR prices are £797 UK, US$997 US and CAD$1,497 Canada monthly, not market salary benchmarks. Compare like-for-like responsibilities, availability and total commitments before declaring one model cheaper.
Can a small business outsource PR without having a marketing department?
Yes, if it has a responsive decision-maker and somebody with genuine knowledge of the business. An external team can research appropriate journalists, prepare content, develop credible angles and handle the agreed outreach, but it cannot provide facts or rights that the company has not supplied. Identify one internal contact who can confirm product details, approve accurate statements, provide images and make a spokesperson available. A modest organisational process is often sufficient, even without a marketing team. If the founder cannot spare time for basic evidence and approvals, the company may need to establish those foundations before paying for external PR.
Should PR sit with the founder, an employee or an outside agency?
Responsibility should follow the actual job. The founder often controls the most authentic business knowledge and final decisions. A capable employee may be best placed to coordinate daily internal information, stakeholders and deadlines. An outside agency may add specialist editorial judgement and direct media outreach where the company lacks that expertise or cannot justify a full-time hire. Many lean businesses work well with a simple hybrid: one internal approval owner and an agreed external delivery scope. No arrangement can make an editor publish a story. Review time, budget, confidentiality and continuity rather than assuming one organisation chart always produces better PR.
What happens if we outsource PR and the media do not cover us?
Ask what work was agreed and completed before concluding that the retainer produced nothing. Review the actual angles developed, relevance of targeted journalists, factual material, follow-up and any credible media interest. Independent outlets may be slow or may decline entirely. A capable agency should explain what was learnt, which ideas need refinement and whether the business has sufficient editorial potential to continue. Equally, 'PR takes time' should not excuse missing reporting or indefinite inactivity. Use the actual contract period and cancellation terms, discuss realistic changes with the account team and make a commercial decision based on evidence, not a promised number of articles.
Thinking about outsourcing PR for your business?
If your business has authentic expertise, a useful product or a credible story but little time to turn it into journalist-ready material, Fair PR can help assess whether a scoped external programme is sensible. Learn how our outsourced PR approach works and compare Standard PR with the narrower Expert Commentary PR service before making a commitment. Tell us what your business needs, which audience matters and which facts you can substantiate. We will discuss practical scope, costs, your responsibilities and realistic limits. If a capable in-house employee, DIY preparation or a one-off project would serve you better, it is more useful to say so than sell a retainer that does not fit.
About the author
Jordan Baker founded Fair Public Relations after working as a UK national journalist. An experienced PR consultant, he helps founders and knowledgeable professionals develop source material and stories that can genuinely help journalists.
View Jordan Baker's media expert profile