By Jordan Baker, Founder of Fair Public Relations and former UK national journalist
When two PR agency proposals land in your inbox, compare the work they actually promise, the media approach, who will do it, how you will review progress, the full contractual cost and what the agency cannot control. A lower fee for pitching an established expert as a source is not the same service as developing a company's founder story, product campaign and ongoing media positioning. A longer proposal is not necessarily a better one, and neither provider can guarantee that an independent editor will publish a particular article.
I am Jordan Baker, a former UK national journalist and the founder of Fair Public Relations. If I were spending my own company's money on PR, I would not begin by ranking agencies according to the biggest publication logo on the cover page. I would read the actual offer, find the claimed story and ask why somebody responsible for a publication would consider it useful. Then I would check the delivery, evidence, exclusions and cost. This guide begins at the point where you have received a proposal and must decide whether to sign it.
What should a good PR proposal actually tell you?
At minimum, a proposal should explain what the business wants to achieve, which audiences matter and which forms of legitimate publicity could serve them. It should define the work that the agency will undertake, the person responsible, the client's contribution, the fee, the starting period and how both sides will evaluate progress. A concise proposal that answers those questions can be better than a polished forty-page document that never says what happens next.
Specific language is useful. 'We will develop appropriate story angles from your professional expertise, prepare approved written material and pitch selected journalists who cover the subject' describes actions the agency controls. 'We will position you as an industry leader and achieve widespread media exposure' is a desirable ambition without a workable method. The buyer should be able to point to the actual deliverables, not infer them from adjectives.
A proposal does not need to disclose private reporter contact details or an agency's entire internal database to demonstrate competence. It should be able to identify relevant editorial categories, suggest credible angles and explain how enquiries and follow-up will be handled. A specialist accountant might reasonably be pitched to finance and business journalists seeking qualified commentary. A consumer product might instead require samples, imagery, suitable review editors and a founder interview.
Check the document for scope boundaries as well as promises. Does it include press-release drafting or only pitching? Is an initial strategy session part of the fee? Who supplies research, quotes, photos and compliance approval? If the answer is unclear, ask for a written clarification before comparing the proposal with another.
Does the agency understand what makes your business newsworthy?
An agency can write that you are innovative, disruptive or passionate in almost any proposal. Those words are not sufficient reasons for a reporter to write a story. Journalists need something timely, useful, unusual, verifiable or directly relevant to their readers. The proposal should show at least one realistic path from your genuine knowledge or business activity to that editorial need.
For example, a business founder with first-hand experience of supplier shortages could explain the practical consequences of a documented industry problem. A properly qualified professional could offer context on a public development, with evidence for specific claims. A product launch may be relevant to an editor if the item solves a recognisable problem, is genuinely available and can be independently assessed. A routine internal milestone may have little news value outside a local or niche context.
As a former journalist, I would be more interested in the agency that challenges a weak premise than the one that agrees every company announcement deserves national coverage. Ask the proposer to explain why its strongest suggested pitch might be rejected. Can it identify the proof that is missing, the likely reader and an appropriate alternative format? Those are meaningful signs of editorial judgement.
That does not mean a good agency can predict what an editor will publish. The plan should be plausible, not certain. A thoughtful proposal may say that an expert quote is more realistic than a founder profile, or that a launch needs stronger assets before pitching. Those observations can save money by preventing a campaign built around a story that has not yet been established.
Are you comparing the same kind of PR service?
This is where apparent price gaps become misleading. One provider may offer a narrow service that takes a media-ready individual expert's genuine commentary, prepares responses and pitches relevant reporters. Another may offer strategic positioning, founder interviews, product and service publicity, ongoing story development and a named account manager. Both might call their activity 'media outreach', yet the labour and intended editorial formats differ substantially.
Other offers may be one-off product-launch projects, generic newswire distribution, corporate crisis communications, influencer partnerships or sponsored articles. None is automatically wrong, but the buyer should know what is being purchased. A press release posted to a distribution feed is not a journalist independently writing about the business. A paid advertorial is not the same as earned reporting.
Make two columns in your notes: work expressly included and work expressly excluded. Add positioning, angle development, research, writing, contact selection, pitching, media enquiries, interviews, reporting, social content, product samples and strategic advice as relevant. A phrase such as 'unlimited PR opportunities' is not meaningful unless the limits and nature of the work are defined.
Fair PR's Our Services page distinguishes Standard PR for wider founder, company, product and service campaigns from Expert Commentary PR for eligible specialists seeking a narrower commentary-focused service. If a company wants its first consumer product reviewed, it should not compare a quote-only service with a full product-publicity proposal as though they were equivalent.
Who will actually do the work?
The salesperson may have impressive journalism experience, but who will carry out the research and daily pitching? Ask who leads the account, who writes the material, who checks specialist facts and who handles journalist responses. Senior oversight is valuable when it involves actual editorial decisions, not simply a name printed in the proposal.
Small teams can work well. In some cases a founder remains involved in strategy while experienced colleagues deliver the daily work. A larger team can also have advantages when the brief involves multiple countries, events or complex approvals. Neither structure guarantees a better result. The issue is whether someone has clear responsibility and enough relevant capacity.
If a journalist requests a correction at short notice, who can act? If a technical claim is challenged, who obtains evidence from the client? If an agreed angle proves weak, who has authority to change direction? An accountable delivery system matters more than a diagram of senior job titles that never translates into a practical response.
Ask about handovers, absences and the time the client must make available. A proposal that requires weekly interviews, product approvals and extensive original research may be entirely reasonable, but only if the buyer has somebody capable of providing them. Good PR is collaborative work, not an agency independently inventing a client's professional knowledge.
How much actual work does the proposal promise each month?
A reasonable proposal describes agency-controlled activity clearly enough that you can tell whether it took place. That can involve an initial positioning discussion, research of appropriate stories, factual drafting, targeted reporter approaches, follow-up, responses to enquiries and a candid progress report. The mix will change when journalists show interest or the market changes.
Be wary of treating the number of emails as a stand-in for quality. Fifty generic messages sent to irrelevant writers may involve less editorial judgement than five genuinely appropriate, researched approaches. At the same time, a supplier should not use 'quality over quantity' as an excuse to provide no visible work, no explanation and no sign that the campaign has developed.
A useful proposal separates controllable deliverables from uncertain outputs. An agency can commit to producing a researched pitch within the agreed scope; it cannot commit an independent reporter to feature it. A journalist's acknowledgement, a request for information, a completed interview and a published story are different stages and should not be collapsed into one success count.
Look for a sensible reporting rhythm rather than arbitrary volume. A client should know what angles have been prepared, which media categories were approached, what questions came back and what will be changed if little is resonating. The existing Fair PR guide to what a PR agency does each month covers the activity in more detail; a proposal needs to explain which parts apply to this buyer.
Does the proposal promise coverage nobody can control?
A guarantee of coverage in a named independent national newspaper by a fixed date deserves clarification. The editor, not the PR agency, decides whether a story is published and how it is framed. The same distinction applies to a promised editorial backlink, a guaranteed Google ranking or a claim that an AI assistant will cite the company. Those outcomes depend on third parties and cannot be contracted as though they were agency-owned inventory.
There are legitimate paid alternatives. A publisher may sell a sponsored feature with an agreed placement, price and disclosure rules. The supplier should describe that as advertising or sponsored content under the applicable arrangement, not quietly present it as an independent editorial recommendation. The PRSA Code of Ethics provides useful principles around honesty and disclosure, without endorsing any particular agency.
Sometimes a proposal's language is imprecise rather than deliberately misleading. 'Guaranteed press' might refer to a distribution service that posts a company release to participating websites, or a commercial content placement. Ask exactly what the guarantee covers, who selects the content, whether the buyer pays a publisher and how a reader will know it is sponsored.
I would prefer a provider that says what it will do if independent editors do not respond. A responsible approach might involve changing the angle, supplying stronger source material or recommending another communications route. It should not invent a publication promise to make the sales conversation easier.
What results and milestones should you expect to see?
Agree a review framework before work begins. The first questions concern whether the business has been understood, the source materials are accurate and the story directions are genuinely plausible. Later, the client should be able to identify relevant work, interest from reporters and any finished public coverage. None of those should be confused with a particular volume guarantee.
The AMEC Integrated Evaluation Framework is helpful here. It distinguishes what communicators do from the outputs they generate, audience responses, outcomes and eventual organisational impact. That does not mean a small business needs a complicated analytics department. It means the report should not present pitches sent as equivalent to independent coverage, or count every website visit as attributable revenue.
For one founder, a relevant interview request from a technical trade reporter may be a meaningful early sign that the positioning has improved. For a consumer product business, accurate images supplied and a review sample requested could indicate genuine activity, even though the publication may later decline to run the product. The buyer should expect honest status updates rather than a fictional publication date.
Specify when the parties will review strategy and what evidence can prompt a change. An initial period without a published article is not automatically failure, but neither is it a reason to accept indefinite vagueness. If the agency cannot explain what was done, what was learnt and what comes next, accountability is missing.
How should you compare fees without choosing the cheapest?
Calculate the fee for the actual commitment period first, then identify expenses that may fall outside it. An offer that appears less expensive monthly can cost more over a longer minimum term, or require separately charged work that another provider includes. The opposite can also happen: an expensive broad communications proposal may include services a small company genuinely does not need.
Use Fair PR's published fees as concrete examples, not market averages. Current Standard PR costs £797 per month for UK clients, US$997 for US clients or CAD$1,497 for Canadian clients. Three initial monthly charges total £2,391, US$2,991 or CAD$4,491 respectively, before applicable taxes or separately agreed third-party expenses. Eligible Expert Commentary PR costs £397, US$497 or CAD$747 monthly, giving three-charge totals of £1,191, US$1,491 or CAD$2,241. The figures are distinct market prices, not currency conversions.
Those two Fair PR prices buy different scopes. Standard PR addresses broader strategy, founder positioning, product/service stories and account-managed pitching. Expert Commentary focuses on qualified individuals contributing authentic professional comments and suitable expert-led angles. Buying the narrower option for a product launch would be a poor comparison even if its three-month price looked attractive.
For any proposal, ask who pays for photographs, sample shipping, specialist fact-checking, media training, events, travel or paid placements. Some are necessary only for particular campaigns and may be direct client expenses rather than agency charges. Cost matters, but the meaningful measure is whether the total outlay buys the relevant professional work at a level the company can sustain.
What should you check about contract length and cancellation?
Read the contract, not merely the pricing slide. Identify the initial term, whether renewal is automatic, what notice is required after the first period and precisely how cancellation must be communicated. Ask about invoice timing, any minimum notice before a renewal date, separately approved expenses and what happens to work already underway when the agreement ends.
Fair PR's current services begin with a three-month commitment and require one full billing cycle's notice afterwards under the applicable terms. That is not the same as a cancel-anytime subscription or an option to pause without notice. A buyer should be clear about the financial obligation before signing, even when the monthly number appears manageable.
Ownership and use of materials also need attention. Can the business reuse an approved biography or press release? Who owns photographs commissioned for the campaign? Are draft pitches and contact information covered by confidentiality or reuse conditions? Different agreements may treat these questions differently, so do not assume every asset transfers automatically.
If the contract is substantial or unusually complex, obtain appropriate professional advice. A PR blog is not a legal interpretation of any particular supplier's agreement. What matters is that there should be no uncomfortable surprise about fees, notice, work in progress or the respective responsibilities of the client and agency.
What can case studies prove, and what can they not?
A useful case study shows what happened in an actual campaign, the client's relevant story, the kind of work undertaken and independently checkable examples of published media. It can demonstrate that an agency has experience with particular editorial formats. It cannot show that a new client will receive the same volume of attention, in the same time or at the same fee.
For example, Fair PR's historical Moonbird product and expert-led case records 25 published articles across 20 publication titles during a six-month campaign. That is evidence about a specific brand with particular source material, product relevance and timing. It is not a promise of an equivalent monthly number for another business. The underlying published examples matter more than the headline figure alone.
Likewise, the One Less Thing historical case records articles and editorial links within a defined period, alongside a change in a third-party domain metric. A backlink, publication and independent customer sale are different measurements. An improvement in a third-party SEO metric cannot by itself prove that PR caused the movement, never mind guarantee the same effect for somebody else.
Click original published articles where possible. Check the domain, the spokesperson's actual contribution and whether the article is original reporting, a syndication or commercial content. Ask the agency to distinguish a real expert quotation from a full founder profile. Good previous results help you judge competence; they do not transfer the independent publisher's future decisions into the agency's control.
What warning signs should you notice in a PR proposal?
One warning sign is a document that sounds personalised but contains no demonstrable understanding of the business. The company name may appear on every page while the editorial ideas could fit virtually any client. Another is a list of famous outlets without an explanation of why their reporters would have any interest in the source.
Be cautious with vague scope: 'regular media outreach', 'full PR support' or 'ongoing visibility' without a named delivery team, reporting arrangement or clear exclusions. Also question a promise of instant national features, fixed numbers of earned backlinks or guaranteed AI citations. Ask whether the agency means independent reporting, paid commercial coverage, distribution or a mixture.
Uncheckable case studies, pressure to sign without reading the terms, unexplained fees and an unwillingness to describe client responsibilities all deserve examination. An agency that claims its journalists are obliged to publish because of personal relationships is making a particularly questionable representation of editorial independence.
Not every omission proves a supplier is dishonest. A small proposal may simply need a better scope appendix or an ordinary clarification call. Send precise questions in writing and evaluate the responses. How a provider handles a reasonable request for detail may reveal more about future working arrangements than the first document itself.
Can you compare two proposals using one practical scorecard?
Use the same criteria for both offers: whether the campaign fits your objective, whether at least one news angle is plausible, who delivers the work, what is included, whether editorial outcomes are described honestly, how progress will be reported and what the full commitment costs. Add how much of your own team's time each proposal needs. A buyer cannot make a fair decision by comparing only price and a list of desired publications.
The complete comparison table in the accompanying implementation pack sets out each criterion, what to compare and a specific question to ask. For practical use, I would mark each line as a must-have, a benefit or a non-fit. If your central requirement is product reviews, for instance, a specialist commentary-only programme that excludes product publicity is a non-fit regardless of the price. If you want occasional expert quotations, a costly corporate issues programme may be unnecessary.
| Criterion | What to compare | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Campaign fit | Does the scope actually address company publicity, product stories, founder positioning or only specialist commentary? | Which of our stated business goals will you work on, and what is expressly excluded? |
| Editorial angle | At least one plausible reader-focused story backed by real knowledge, dates or evidence rather than a generic promise | Why would a reporter covering this subject genuinely need our perspective? |
| Delivery and oversight | Named daily lead, writer, reporter contact management, factual review, senior involvement and cover for absence | Who takes responsibility for our account and urgent editorial questions? |
| Agency-controlled work | Research, interviews, drafting, selected outreach, revisions, follow-up and client updates actually included | What will you do during the first month and how will we see that work? |
| Independent editorial honesty | Separation of genuine editorial requests, possible articles, paid advertisements and press-release distribution | Which results depend on an editor, and are any paid placements being proposed? |
| Evidence and reporting | Real public coverage links, correct source attribution, meaningful media feedback, review dates and clear status changes | How will you distinguish pitched stories, reporter interest, held interviews and published coverage? |
| Fees and commitment | Market-specific monthly fee, minimum charges, notice, taxes if applicable, third-party expenses and content rights | What is our total initial commitment and the exact process and cost for ending it? |
| Client responsibility | Time for expert input, approvals, factual evidence, interview availability, product imagery and specialist sign-off | What do you need from us, who must supply it and how quickly? |
Consider two explicitly fictional proposals. The first is for an accountant with real technical knowledge who mainly wants timely journalist quotes. The second is for a small consumer brand preparing its first product launch, requiring imagery, samples, a founder story and wider positioning. Both could be well executed, yet scoring them against one generic 'number of press releases' target would be meaningless.
A scorecard is an aid to judgement, not a scientific ranking. Avoid inventing weighted percentages or declaring the provider with the highest score objectively superior. Use it to identify the questions that would change your buying decision. If one offer is clearly irrelevant, do not let its attractive fee obscure that.
Five sensible questions to send before signing
You do not need a formal procurement process to get useful answers. Five polite, specific questions can usually tell you whether the seller has thought through your particular brief. Send them after you have read the proposal, not as a generic test detached from the services the agency actually offers.
First: 'Which specific work will your team deliver in our first month, and which tasks or expenses are outside the fee?' Second: 'What is your most credible editorial angle for our business, and what evidence would you need from us to pursue it responsibly?' Third: 'Who would lead our account day to day, and how would you handle an urgent reporter request or factual correction?'
Fourth: 'How will your progress report distinguish completed research and pitching from journalist interest and independently published articles?' Fifth: 'What are the full initial fees, renewal and cancellation terms, and any other contractual steps we would need to take to end the arrangement?'
A strong answer does not need to promise publications. It needs to describe actions, responsibilities, limitations and a credible process for learning from media responses. If the answers contradict the original proposal, request an amended written scope rather than relying on somebody's verbal reassurance.
When is a good PR proposal still wrong for your business?
An agency can be competent and still be an unsuitable purchase. A founder expecting immediate paid customer acquisition may need a more directly controlled marketing channel. A product launching tomorrow without photographs, stock, substantiation or available samples may not be ready for a review-led campaign. A specialist whose technical evidence remains unresolved may need professional validation before publicity.
Budget can also make the timing wrong. If the business cannot meet the full initial commitment without depending on a guaranteed article to generate sales, it may be safer to delay. Earned media runs on editors' schedules and news priorities, not a client's next billing date. Spending money that the company needs for product readiness can make the work less effective.
Client capacity matters. Even a well-resourced agency cannot honestly answer a journalist's questions about a founder's first-hand experience without their involvement. If nobody can approve materials, provide proof or meet interview requests, the partnership may struggle regardless of how convincing the pitch ideas are.
Sometimes DIY preparation, improved customer information, stronger owned content, a separate paid campaign or a later launch is the rational recommendation. The right provider should be comfortable saying so. Do not sign solely because you like the consultant or fear missing an opportunity that has not been demonstrated.
How does Fair PR explain its own proposals and services?
Fair Public Relations is a journalist-led boutique PR agency offering two distinct levels of suitable support. Our Services explains the difference. Expert Commentary PR is for individually eligible professionals who have useful, credible expertise and want research, appropriate comments, journalist outreach and follow-up handled. Standard PR is broader, including founder and authority positioning, brand or product story development, proactive and reactive pitching and account-managed support.
The current Standard PR monthly fees are £797 in the UK, US$997 in the US and CAD$1,497 in Canada. The narrower Expert Commentary PR prices are £397, US$497 and CAD$747. Each service has an initial three-month term followed by one full billing-cycle notice. The difference is substantive scope, not an agency promise that spending twice as much buys twice as many independent articles.
The work depends on your real material. A qualified specialist with clear subjects may be a fit for focused commentary. A company wanting a wider founder story or consumer product publicity needs a broader campaign. We should tell you if the available facts do not support the story you had hoped to pitch. We cannot promise the journalist's final decision, editorial links, Google rankings, AI citations or customers.
If you receive a Fair PR proposal, please check it against these descriptions and ask which tasks, source materials and reporting apply to your business. I would rather explain the limit of an appropriate service in advance than encourage someone to buy a plan that is not designed for their objective.
So which proposal should you choose?
Choose the offer whose actual work is relevant, whose proposed editorial route makes sense and whose financial commitment is manageable. The agency should demonstrate that it understands your audience, recognises the boundaries of earned media, has accountable people delivering the service and can tell you what will happen if the first ideas are not useful to reporters.
The cheapest offer is not necessarily poor, and the most expensive is not necessarily the strongest. A small focused programme may be exactly right for a media-ready specialist, while a growing business with several publicity routes may need broader strategy. An offer that includes many impressive services can still be wasteful when most of them have no relevance to the client's immediate goals.
If an important point is unclear, ask one more question before signing. A credible provider will be willing to explain the proposal in plain English. You should not have to interpret vague promises, guess your cancellation commitment or assume that journalist interest is guaranteed publication. A good proposal provides a basis for trust because its scope is understandable even when the results remain uncertain.
Frequently asked questions
Should I choose the PR proposal with the lowest monthly price?
Only when the actual service is suitable and the full commitment makes sense. A £397 expert-commentary service and a £797 wider PR programme at Fair PR are different jobs, not two prices for identical work. Compare the relevant campaign route, writing and pitching deliverables, account support, client responsibilities, exclusions, taxes and separately agreed expenses. Calculate the minimum-term cost and read the notice provisions. An inexpensive proposal can be excellent when it fits your situation; a costly one can still be wrong. Neither fee guarantees that an independent editor will publish an article, supply a backlink or generate enquiries.
Is a guaranteed number of newspaper articles a normal PR deliverable?
An agency can commit to actions it controls, such as researching an angle, drafting approved copy, approaching suitable reporters and reporting on responses. It cannot force an independent newspaper to publish a story or include a link. A paid media placement may have a separately agreed schedule and deliverable, but that is an advertising arrangement rather than ordinary earned editorial coverage and requires appropriate disclosure. If a proposal promises a fixed number of 'press hits', ask whether those mean original reported articles, syndicated press-release copies, paid placements or something else. Get the definition in writing before comparing the quote with a genuine earned-media offer.
What should I do if two PR agencies promise very different results?
Start by asking whether they are offering the same service. One may be describing original editorial pitching while another includes advertising, newswire distribution or an entirely different campaign scope. Ask for actual published examples, the proposed editorial audience, work the agency controls and a clear explanation of third-party decisions. A provider's enthusiastic forecast is not necessarily dishonest, but a promise of independent editorial publication on a fixed date needs particular scrutiny. Check how each team would respond to rejection, what would be reported and how long you would be committed. Make the comparison against your business needs rather than assuming the highest predicted article count must be the best offer.
What contract details should I check before signing with a PR agency?
Check the initial term, total fees, billing dates, automatic continuation, renewal and cancellation notice. Confirm any required cancellation method and how a final billing period works. Ask who approves additional expenses, owns commissioned imagery or written assets and remains responsible for legal or specialist review of claims. The scope should identify exclusions and client obligations so an urgent journalist deadline does not become a dispute. The contract may also contain confidentiality and reuse conditions for materials or pitches. Do not rely solely on a verbal summary, and seek qualified advice if an unusual or high-value clause affects your rights. Understanding the agreement is part of choosing a financially appropriate service.
Looking for PR with a clear scope and realistic expectations?
Fair PR can help suitable founders, experts and small businesses work out which genuine earned-media route fits their situation. Compare the separate scopes on our Our Services page, or read Standard PR and Expert Commentary PR directly before making a decision. If you have a particular story or professional background you would like us to assess, get in touch and tell us what you can substantiate, whom you want to reach and what you can realistically spend. We will discuss the work and its limitations rather than promise a named publication, backlink, Google position or sales result. If your proposal would be better handled by another route, it is more useful to recognise that before anybody signs a contract.
About the author
Jordan Baker is the founder of Fair Public Relations, a former UK national journalist and an experienced PR consultant. He helps founders and credible specialists shape their professional knowledge into useful journalism, while explaining clearly which editorial outcomes remain beyond an agency's control.
View Jordan Baker's media expert profile